Table of Contents

Subordination in Real Estate: Understanding Lien Priority

Subordination in real estate is a contractual agreement that alters the priority of liens against a property. In essence, it’s an agreement where a lienholder agrees to lower their claim’s priority to a subsequent lienholder. This means that in the event of a foreclosure, the lienholder who has subordinated their claim will be paid after the lienholder who now has a higher priority. This is a critical concept to grasp when navigating real estate financing and investment.

Why Subordination Matters: The Lien Waterfall

Think of liens as a waterfall, cascading down to the property’s value. The top waterfall gets the first drink, the next one gets what’s left, and so on. When a property owner takes out multiple loans secured by the same property, each loan creates a lien. The order in which these liens were recorded generally determines their priority. This is commonly known as the “first in time, first in right” rule. However, subordination throws a wrench into this simple system.

Subordination allows a lienholder, perhaps a first mortgage lender, to agree to take a lower priority than a subsequent mortgage lender, such as one providing a home equity line of credit (HELOC) or a second mortgage. This is typically done via a subordination agreement, a legally binding document outlining the specific terms of the agreement.

The implications are significant. Imagine a homeowner defaults on their mortgage payments and the property is foreclosed upon. The lienholders are paid off in order of priority. If the first mortgage lender has not subordinated their lien, they get paid first, up to the outstanding balance of their loan, plus any accrued interest and foreclosure costs. Only then does the second mortgage lender get paid. If the property doesn’t sell for enough to cover both debts, the second mortgage lender, in this scenario, takes a loss. However, if the first mortgage lender has subordinated, the new lender gets paid first.

Common Scenarios Where Subordination is Used

Refinancing Existing Mortgages

Subordination often comes into play when a homeowner refinances their first mortgage. The new lender wants to be in the “first lien” position. This means the original first mortgage holder needs to agree to subordinate their position to the new lender’s mortgage. It’s a standard part of the refinancing process.

Home Equity Lines of Credit (HELOCs) and Second Mortgages

When a homeowner takes out a HELOC or a second mortgage, these loans are generally junior liens to the existing first mortgage. However, sometimes the first mortgage documents require any subsequent financing to be subordinated to the first mortgage, reaffirming the senior position of the first mortgage lender.

Construction Loans

Construction loans are frequently involved in subordination agreements. A developer might own land with an existing mortgage. To secure financing for construction, the existing mortgage holder may need to subordinate their lien to the construction lender, allowing the construction lender to have the first claim on the completed project. This makes the project more attractive to potential lenders who need assurance that they’ll be paid first if the project goes south.

Ground Leases

In a ground lease situation, a developer leases land and builds a property on it. The ground lease may require the landowner to subordinate their interest in the land to the developer’s construction financing, again making it easier for the developer to secure funding.

The Subordination Agreement: A Deep Dive

The subordination agreement is the heart of the process. It’s a legal document that explicitly outlines the agreement between the lienholders. Key elements usually include:

Identification of Parties: Clearly identifies all parties involved, including the borrower, the senior lienholder, and the junior lienholder.
Description of the Properties: Provides a legal description of the property subject to the liens.
Loan Details: Specifies the amounts, interest rates, and other relevant details of both the senior and junior loans.
Subordination Clause: The core of the agreement, explicitly stating that the senior lienholder agrees to subordinate their lien to the junior lienholder.
Conditions: Outlines any conditions that must be met for the subordination to be effective. This might include requirements related to loan-to-value ratios or project completion milestones.
Governing Law: Specifies the jurisdiction whose laws will govern the interpretation and enforcement of the agreement.

Potential Risks and Considerations

While subordination can be beneficial for all parties involved, it’s essential to be aware of the potential risks:

For the Subordinating Lienholder: The biggest risk is that the borrower defaults, and the property doesn’t generate enough proceeds to cover both liens. The subordinated lienholder may suffer a significant loss.
For the Borrower: Subordination can make it easier to obtain financing, but it’s crucial to understand the implications of potentially losing the property if they default on either loan.
Proper Documentation: Any poorly drafted or ambiguously worded subordination agreement can lead to costly legal disputes.

Seeking Professional Advice

Navigating subordination agreements requires expertise. Consult with a real estate attorney and a financial advisor to fully understand the risks and benefits before entering into any agreement. Don’t rely solely on the lender’s advice, as their interests may not perfectly align with yours.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What happens if a lender refuses to subordinate?

If a lender refuses to subordinate, the borrower might be unable to obtain the necessary financing. This could prevent them from refinancing, accessing home equity, or proceeding with a construction project. The borrower may need to explore alternative financing options or renegotiate with the lender.

2. Is subordination always necessary when refinancing?

Yes, it is generally necessary when refinancing. The new lender will want to have the first lien position to protect their investment. The existing lender will need to subordinate their claim to allow the new lender to take that position.

3. What is a “subordination, non-disturbance, and attornment agreement” (SNDA)?

An SNDA is common in commercial real estate, particularly with leases. It involves three key promises: Subordination of the tenant’s lease to the landlord’s lender, Non-disturbance, ensuring the tenant can continue their lease if the property is foreclosed upon, and Attornment, meaning the tenant agrees to recognize the lender as their new landlord if the property changes hands.

4. Can a subordination agreement be reversed?

Reversing a subordination agreement is difficult, but it may be possible under specific circumstances, such as if there was fraud or misrepresentation involved in the original agreement. It’s essential to seek legal advice in such situations.

5. How does subordination affect title insurance?

Title insurance companies carefully examine subordination agreements to ensure they are valid and enforceable. They may require additional endorsements to cover any potential risks associated with the subordination.

6. What is a blanket subordination agreement?

A blanket subordination agreement subordinates all present and future liens held by one party to those of another. These are less common than specific agreements, but they can be used in ongoing lending relationships.

7. What due diligence should I perform before agreeing to a subordination?

Perform thorough due diligence on the borrower and the project. Analyze the financial viability of the project and the borrower’s ability to repay the loans. Obtain independent appraisals and consult with legal and financial professionals.

8. Are there tax implications associated with subordination?

Generally, subordination itself doesn’t trigger immediate tax consequences. However, the underlying financial transactions (refinancing, taking out a HELOC) may have tax implications. Consult with a tax advisor.

9. How does subordination differ from a release of lien?

A subordination agreement changes the priority of liens, whereas a release of lien removes a lien entirely from the property.

10. What happens if the subordination agreement is not properly recorded?

If the subordination agreement is not properly recorded, it may not be enforceable against third parties. This can create significant title issues and legal disputes.

11. Can a second mortgage lender force a first mortgage lender to subordinate?

No, a second mortgage lender cannot force a first mortgage lender to subordinate unless there is a pre-existing contractual obligation to do so. Subordination is a voluntary agreement.

12. What role does the title company play in a subordination?

The title company facilitates the execution and recording of the subordination agreement, ensuring that it is properly documented and becomes part of the public record. They also provide title insurance to protect against any defects or issues related to the subordination.