Table of Contents

Can I Get a Second Dental Insurance Policy? The Expert’s Verdict

Yes, absolutely! You can get a second dental insurance policy. While it’s permissible, the real question is whether it’s financially beneficial and strategically smart for your specific situation. Let’s dive deep into the complexities, benefits, and potential pitfalls of double dental coverage.

Decoding Double Dental Coverage: Is It Right for You?

The allure of double dental insurance stems from the desire to maximize coverage, minimize out-of-pocket expenses, and access a broader network of dentists. It’s a strategy akin to hedging your bets, but it’s crucial to understand the intricacies before jumping in.

The Coordination of Benefits (COB) Dance

The primary factor determining the value of having two dental insurance policies is the Coordination of Benefits (COB) process. COB rules dictate how insurance companies handle claims when a person is covered by more than one plan. In essence, one plan becomes the primary insurer, paying first, while the other becomes the secondary insurer, potentially covering some or all of the remaining balance.

Understanding how these plans coordinate is paramount. Generally, the “birthday rule” applies: the plan covering the policyholder whose birthday falls earlier in the calendar year becomes the primary insurer. However, there are exceptions, particularly if one policy is through an employer and the other is an individual plan. Employer-sponsored plans typically take precedence.

The Potential Advantages: More Than Meets the Eye

Increased Coverage Limits: A second policy could help you exceed annual maximums, a significant advantage if you anticipate needing extensive dental work.
Wider Network Access: Access to a larger pool of dentists through combined networks. This is particularly helpful if your preferred dentist isn’t in your primary plan’s network.
Coverage for More Procedures: Some plans might cover procedures that others don’t. A second policy can potentially bridge these gaps in coverage.
Reduced Out-of-Pocket Costs: The secondary plan can cover a portion of what the primary plan doesn’t, potentially lowering your overall expenses.

The Potential Disadvantages: Hidden Costs and Limitations

Premiums: Paying for two dental insurance policies means double the premiums. You need to analyze whether the benefits outweigh these costs.
Limitations in COB: Not all plans fully cover the remaining balance after the primary insurer pays. Some plans have strict limitations, negating the value of the second policy.
Waiting Periods: Second policies may also have waiting periods for certain procedures, delaying immediate access to expanded coverage.
Administrative Hassle: Dealing with multiple insurance companies can be tedious, involving additional paperwork and claim submissions.
Potential for Limited Reimbursement: Some policies have clauses stating that they will only pay up to what they would have paid if they were the primary insurer, limiting the actual benefit.

Evaluating Your Needs: A Personalized Approach

Before investing in a second policy, carefully evaluate your dental needs.

Assess Your Dental Health: Do you anticipate needing extensive dental work, like implants, orthodontics, or major restorative procedures?
Analyze Your Current Coverage: Understand the limits, deductibles, and covered procedures of your existing plan.
Compare Policy Options: Research different dental insurance plans, paying close attention to their coverage, networks, and COB policies.
Calculate Potential Costs and Savings: Estimate the premiums, deductibles, and potential out-of-pocket costs for both plans. Then, compare this total to the potential savings on dental procedures.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Double Dental Insurance

Here are the answers to some of the most common questions about obtaining and utilizing multiple dental insurance policies:

1. Is it legal to have two dental insurance policies?

Yes, it is perfectly legal to have two dental insurance policies. There are no laws preventing individuals from holding multiple insurance policies, including dental insurance.

2. How does Coordination of Benefits (COB) work with dental insurance?

Coordination of Benefits (COB) determines which insurance policy pays first when you have multiple policies. Typically, the “birthday rule” applies, making the policy of the parent whose birthday falls earlier in the year the primary payer for dependents. However, employer-sponsored plans usually take precedence over individual plans. The secondary insurer then covers some or all of the remaining balance, depending on the policy’s terms.

3. What is the “birthday rule” in dental insurance?

The “birthday rule” is a common guideline in COB. It dictates that the dental insurance policy of the parent whose birthday falls earlier in the calendar year is the primary insurer for dependent children. For example, if one parent’s birthday is in March and the other’s is in August, the policy associated with the parent born in March would be primary.

4. Will having two dental insurance policies always reduce my out-of-pocket costs?

Not necessarily. While a second policy can potentially reduce out-of-pocket costs, it depends on the specific policies’ coverage, deductibles, and COB rules. If the secondary policy has significant limitations or doesn’t adequately cover the remaining balance after the primary insurer pays, you might not see a substantial reduction in costs.

5. Can I choose which dental insurance policy is primary?

Generally, no. The COB rules, such as the “birthday rule” or the precedence of employer-sponsored plans, dictate which policy is primary. You cannot typically choose which policy pays first.

6. Do dental insurance policies have waiting periods?

Yes, most dental insurance policies have waiting periods for certain procedures. These waiting periods can range from a few months for basic services like cleanings and exams to a year or more for major procedures like implants, crowns, and orthodontics.

7. How do I file a claim with two dental insurance policies?

First, submit the claim to the primary dental insurance provider. Once you receive the explanation of benefits (EOB) from the primary insurer, submit that EOB along with a claim form to the secondary dental insurance provider.

8. What happens if both of my dental insurance policies have the same coverage?

Even if both policies have similar coverage, the Coordination of Benefits will still apply. The primary insurer will pay first, and the secondary insurer may cover some or all of the remaining balance. The benefit might be minimal if the policies have similar limitations.

9. Are there any situations where having two dental insurance policies is clearly beneficial?

Yes, scenarios where two dental insurance policies are often beneficial include:

When you anticipate needing extensive dental work exceeding the annual maximum of your primary policy.
When you want access to a broader network of dentists.
When one policy covers procedures that the other doesn’t.
When the secondary policy has very low premiums and fills coverage gaps effectively.

10. Can I get reimbursed more than the actual cost of the dental procedure with two insurance policies?

No. Insurance policies are designed to cover your expenses, not to profit from them. The combined reimbursement from both policies cannot exceed the actual cost of the dental procedure.

11. Are there any tax implications to having two dental insurance policies?

The premiums you pay for dental insurance can be tax-deductible if you itemize deductions and your total medical expenses exceed a certain percentage of your adjusted gross income (AGI). Having two policies doesn’t inherently change this, but it might increase the total deductible amount. Consult with a tax professional for personalized advice.

12. Where can I find more information about specific dental insurance policies and their COB rules?

The best place to find detailed information about a specific dental insurance policy is to review the policy documents. You can also contact the insurance provider directly to inquire about their COB rules, coverage details, and any specific limitations. Websites like the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) also provide consumer resources.

The Final Verdict: A Calculated Decision

Ultimately, the decision to obtain a second dental insurance policy should be a carefully considered one. Weigh the potential benefits against the costs, understand the COB process, and assess your individual dental needs. Armed with this knowledge, you can make an informed choice that optimizes your dental health and financial well-being.