Can I Use Two Insurance Plans for Dental Care? Decoding Coordination of Benefits
Yes, you absolutely can use two insurance plans for dental care, but the way it works isn’t as simple as doubling your coverage. This process is called Coordination of Benefits (COB), and it involves a specific set of rules that determine which plan pays first and how much each plan covers. Understanding COB is crucial to maximizing your dental benefits and minimizing out-of-pocket expenses.
Understanding Coordination of Benefits (COB)
COB prevents you from being reimbursed more than 100% of your dental expenses. Think of it as a system that ensures fair and efficient allocation of costs between multiple insurance providers. Without COB, individuals could potentially profit from their dental treatments, which is not the intent of insurance.
How Does COB Work in Dental Insurance?
The insurance companies will coordinate to determine which plan is primary and which is secondary. The primary insurance plan pays first, up to its coverage limits. Then, the claim is submitted to the secondary insurance plan, which may cover some or all of the remaining balance, depending on its terms and limitations.
The Birthday Rule and Other Determinants
Determining which plan is primary often involves specific rules, the most common being the Birthday Rule.
The Birthday Rule Explained
The Birthday Rule typically dictates that the insurance plan of the parent whose birthday falls earlier in the calendar year is primary for dependent children. For instance, if one parent’s birthday is in March and the other’s is in July, the plan of the parent with the March birthday will be the primary insurer. Keep in mind that this rule typically applies regardless of which parent is older.
Beyond the Birthday Rule: Other Scenarios
While the Birthday Rule is common, other scenarios can influence which plan is primary:
Coverage Type: If one plan is through your employer and the other is a private individual plan, the employer-sponsored plan is generally primary.
Court Orders: In cases of divorce or separation, a court order may specify which parent is responsible for providing health or dental insurance, overriding the Birthday Rule.
Federal vs. State Plans: Rules can vary depending on the type of plan. Federal employee plans (FEHB) and other government-sponsored plans may have different COB guidelines.
Submitting Claims with Dual Dental Insurance
Filing claims with two dental insurance plans requires a specific process:
Inform Your Dentist: Let your dental office know that you have dual coverage and provide them with the necessary insurance information for both plans.
Primary Claim Submission: Your dentist will typically submit the claim to the primary insurance company first.
Secondary Claim Submission: After the primary insurance has processed the claim and paid its portion, an Explanation of Benefits (EOB) will be issued. This EOB is then submitted to the secondary insurance company, along with the original dental claim form.
Secondary Payment: The secondary insurance will review the claim and the primary EOB to determine what, if anything, it will pay. It is not guaranteed that the secondary insurance will cover the remaining balance in full.
Potential Benefits and Limitations
Having two dental insurance plans can offer significant advantages, but it’s essential to be aware of the limitations.
Advantages of Dual Dental Coverage
Increased Coverage: You may be able to get a higher percentage of your dental costs covered, potentially reducing your out-of-pocket expenses.
Broader Network Access: If each plan has different networks of dentists, you have a wider selection of providers to choose from.
Higher Annual Maximums: The combined annual maximums from both plans can provide more financial protection for extensive dental work.
Limitations and Considerations
No Double Reimbursement: You cannot receive more than 100% reimbursement for your dental expenses.
Complexity: Managing dual coverage requires understanding the rules of each plan and coordinating claim submissions.
Plan Restrictions: Some plans may have limitations on COB, such as non-duplication clauses, which prevent them from paying if the primary plan already covers a certain percentage.
Cost vs. Benefit: Evaluate the cost of maintaining two separate plans and weigh it against the potential benefits of increased coverage.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Using Two Dental Insurance Plans
Here are some frequently asked questions to further clarify the use of dual dental insurance:
1. What happens if both my spouse and I have dental insurance through our employers?
The Birthday Rule is typically applied to determine which plan is primary for dependent children. However, for your own dental care, your plan is primary for you, and your spouse’s plan is primary for them.
2. My secondary insurance has a non-duplication clause. What does that mean?
A non-duplication clause means that the secondary insurance will only pay if the primary insurance covers less than the secondary plan’s benefit level. It will not pay any additional amount if the primary insurance already paid the same amount or more for the same service. In essence, the secondary plan only kicks in if it offers better coverage than the primary plan for a specific procedure.
3. Will having two dental insurance plans always reduce my out-of-pocket costs?
Not necessarily. While dual coverage can potentially lower your out-of-pocket expenses, it depends on the specific terms of each plan, including deductibles, co-pays, annual maximums, and the services covered. Also, a non-duplication clause might prevent the secondary insurance from paying. You have to carefully consider each policy.
4. How do I know which insurance plan to present to my dentist first?
Inform your dentist’s office that you have dual coverage. They will typically handle the coordination and submit claims to the primary insurance first, based on the information you provide about your insurance plans and the applicable rules (like the Birthday Rule).
5. What information do I need to provide to my dentist for dual insurance coverage?
You will need to provide the dentist’s office with the following information for both insurance plans:
- Insurance company name
- Policyholder’s name
- Policy number
- Group number (if applicable)
- Insurance company phone number
6. Can I choose which dental insurance plan to use as my primary?
Generally, no. The rules of COB, such as the Birthday Rule or the type of plan (employer-sponsored vs. individual), dictate which plan is primary. You cannot typically choose which plan to designate as primary.
7. Are there any dental insurance plans that don’t coordinate benefits?
Some indemnity or fee-for-service plans may not have explicit coordination of benefits provisions, but it is rare. Most managed care plans (HMOs and PPOs) do coordinate benefits to prevent overpayment. It’s essential to review the terms of each plan carefully.
8. What is an Explanation of Benefits (EOB), and why is it important for dual dental insurance?
An Explanation of Benefits (EOB) is a statement from your insurance company that outlines the services you received, the amount billed by the provider, the amount the insurance company paid, and your responsibility (e.g., co-pay, deductible). It’s crucial for dual insurance because you need to submit the primary insurance’s EOB to the secondary insurance company when filing a claim.
9. How do I handle claims if my primary insurance denies coverage for a particular service?
If your primary insurance denies coverage, you should first understand the reason for the denial. If you believe the denial is incorrect, you can appeal the decision with the primary insurance company. If the denial stands, you can still submit the claim and the denial letter to the secondary insurance company, which may cover the service depending on its terms.
10. Does the Birthday Rule apply to divorced or separated parents?
Yes, the Birthday Rule generally still applies to divorced or separated parents. However, a court order can override the Birthday Rule if it specifies which parent is responsible for providing dental insurance for the children.
11. Are there any tax implications for having dual dental insurance coverage?
Generally, no, there are no direct tax implications for having dual dental insurance coverage. The premiums you pay for dental insurance may be tax-deductible if you itemize deductions and your medical expenses exceed a certain percentage of your adjusted gross income. Consult with a tax professional for personalized advice.
12. Is it worth having two dental insurance plans?
Whether it’s worth having two dental insurance plans depends on your individual circumstances, including your dental needs, the cost of each plan, and the potential benefits of dual coverage. Consider factors such as:
- Expected dental expenses: If you anticipate needing extensive dental work, dual coverage may be beneficial.
- Premiums and out-of-pocket costs: Calculate the total cost of both plans, including premiums, deductibles, and co-pays.
- Coverage benefits: Compare the coverage benefits of each plan and assess how dual coverage could reduce your out-of-pocket expenses.
- Coordination of benefits: Understand how the plans coordinate benefits and whether there are any limitations, such as non-duplication clauses.
By carefully evaluating these factors, you can determine whether having two dental insurance plans is a worthwhile investment for your dental health.
Having two dental insurance policies requires a little more administrative work, but the enhanced coverage and broader access to care can often make it worthwhile. Don’t hesitate to contact your insurance providers directly for any specific questions related to your plan and coverage options.
Leave a Reply