Is a 2017 MacBook Still Good? A Seasoned Expert Weighs In

The short answer? It depends. A 2017 MacBook can still be a perfectly viable machine in 2024, but its usability hinges on a few critical factors. We’re talking about its intended use, the specific model (Air vs. Pro), its condition, and perhaps most importantly, your budget. Let’s delve into the nuances.

Decoding the 2017 MacBook: A Mixed Bag

The 2017 MacBook lineup represents a turning point for Apple. We saw both the MacBook Air, largely unchanged from previous generations, and the MacBook Pro, boasting the controversial Touch Bar (on some models) and the introduction of the infamous butterfly keyboard. These distinct variations directly impact whether a 2017 MacBook is a worthwhile investment today.

Performance Considerations: Powering Through 2024

The processors inside these machines, typically Intel Core i5 or i7 chips from the 7th generation Kaby Lake family, aren’t cutting-edge by any stretch. However, for everyday tasks like browsing the web, writing documents, checking emails, and light photo editing, they’re generally sufficient. The MacBook Pro models, especially those with higher-end processors and more RAM (up to 16GB), will obviously handle more demanding tasks better than the MacBook Air or lower-spec Pro configurations. Don’t expect to run the latest AAA games or edit 4K video without experiencing performance hiccups, though.

The Butterfly Keyboard: The Elephant in the Room

Let’s address the biggest drawback: the butterfly keyboard. Known for its shallow key travel and susceptibility to failure from even the smallest particles, this keyboard is a notorious issue. Many 2017 MacBooks have already had their keyboards replaced under Apple’s extended repair program, but the risk of future problems remains. If you’re buying a used 2017 MacBook, thoroughly test the keyboard. Look for sticky keys, unresponsive keys, or unusual sounds. A keyboard replacement might be necessary, and factoring that cost into your budget is crucial.

Display and Ports: Bridging the Gap

The displays on the 2017 MacBooks are generally good. The MacBook Pro models feature brighter, more vibrant displays with wider color gamuts than the MacBook Air. However, neither matches the visual fidelity of modern MacBook Pro displays. The port situation also varies. The MacBook Air retains the older, more familiar ports like USB-A and MagSafe, while the MacBook Pro embraced the USB-C/Thunderbolt 3 standard. This means you might need adapters for older peripherals with the Pro models, but you’ll also benefit from faster data transfer speeds and support for external displays.

Software Support: A Looming Deadline?

Software compatibility is another essential consideration. As of late 2024, the 2017 MacBooks are supported by macOS Ventura. While they received the upgrade to macOS Sonoma, it is not recomended due to slow perfomance. However, Apple’s support windows typically last 5-7 years from the date of release. This means that newer macOS versions may eventually drop support for these models. While older versions of macOS are still functional, they will not receive the latest security updates, making them increasingly vulnerable to malware and other threats.

Battery Life: Manage Your Expectations

Given their age, battery life on used 2017 MacBooks is likely diminished. A battery replacement might be necessary to restore it to its original performance. Expect anywhere from 5-8 hours of real-world use on a MacBook Air with a healthy battery, and perhaps slightly less on the MacBook Pro, especially if you’re pushing the processor.

Verdict: Still a Contender, With Caveats

Ultimately, a 2017 MacBook can still be a useful machine in 2024, particularly for those with light computing needs and a tight budget. However, the potential for keyboard issues, limited software support on the horizon, and degraded battery life are significant drawbacks. If you find one at a compelling price and are aware of these limitations, it could be a worthwhile option. However, consider newer, more reliable models or even a refurbished MacBook if your budget allows.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. How much RAM is enough for a 2017 MacBook in 2024?

8GB of RAM is the minimum you should consider. While the MacBook Air typically only came with 8GB, the MacBook Pro could be configured with 16GB. For more demanding tasks, 16GB is highly recommended to ensure smooth multitasking and avoid slowdowns. Remember that RAM is not upgradeable after purchase.

2. Can I upgrade the storage on a 2017 MacBook?

Unfortunately, no. The storage on both the MacBook Air and MacBook Pro is soldered to the logic board, meaning it cannot be upgraded after purchase. So, choose wisely when purchasing a used model.

3. Is the Touch Bar on the 2017 MacBook Pro useful?

The Touch Bar is a polarizing feature. Some users find it helpful for quick access to context-sensitive controls, while others find it gimmicky and frustrating. Its utility depends entirely on your workflow and preferences. Consider trying one out before committing to a model with the Touch Bar.

4. How can I check the battery health of a used 2017 MacBook?

You can check the battery health by going to System Preferences > Battery > Battery Health. This will show you the battery’s maximum capacity relative to when it was new. Anything below 80% is considered degraded and may warrant a replacement. Also, be sure to check the number of battery cycle counts. The lower the number of battery cycle counts the better the battery life is.

5. What should I look for when buying a used 2017 MacBook?

Thoroughly inspect the keyboard for any issues, check the battery health, examine the display for dead pixels or blemishes, and test all the ports. Ask about the device’s history, including whether it has undergone any repairs, especially keyboard replacements.

6. Is it worth replacing the battery on a 2017 MacBook?

If the battery life is significantly degraded and impacting your usability, a replacement can be worthwhile, especially if the rest of the machine is functioning well. However, factor in the cost of the replacement (which can range from $100 to $200) when deciding if it’s a good investment.

7. Can I still run modern applications on a 2017 MacBook?

Most modern applications should still run on a 2017 MacBook, but some newer or more demanding apps may experience performance issues. Check the system requirements of the applications you intend to use to ensure compatibility.

8. Are there any known security vulnerabilities with older macOS versions?

Yes. Older macOS versions are more susceptible to security vulnerabilities as they no longer receive security updates. This can put your data and privacy at risk. Consider upgrading to the latest supported macOS version or using a more up-to-date machine if security is a major concern.

9. Will a 2017 MacBook be slow compared to a new MacBook?

Yes, a 2017 MacBook will almost certainly feel slower than a new MacBook, especially those powered by Apple’s M-series chips. The newer processors offer significantly better performance and efficiency.

10. What are the main differences between the 2017 MacBook Air and the 2017 MacBook Pro?

The MacBook Air is thinner, lighter, and less powerful, designed for basic tasks. It has an older design, fewer ports (including USB-A), and a lower-resolution display. The MacBook Pro is more powerful, features a brighter and better display, has USB-C/Thunderbolt 3 ports, and (on some models) includes the Touch Bar.

11. How long will Apple continue to provide software updates for the 2017 MacBooks?

Apple typically provides software updates for 5-7 years from the date of release. While the 2017 MacBooks are supported by macOS Ventura. Newer macOS versions will eventually drop support. This also includes security updates so keep this in mind when purchasing a used 2017 MacBook.

12. Should I buy a 2017 MacBook or a newer, used MacBook Air?

In most cases, a newer, used MacBook Air (perhaps a 2018 or later model) would be a better investment. These models offer improved performance, more reliable keyboards, and longer software support. They may cost slightly more, but the benefits generally outweigh the additional expense.