Table of Contents

Is Acorns a Waste of Money? A No-Nonsense Analysis

The short answer? It depends. For some, Acorns is a fantastic gateway into the world of investing, especially for beginners. For others, particularly those with larger investment portfolios or more sophisticated needs, it might not be the most cost-effective solution. Let’s dive deep to figure out if Acorns is the right fit for you.

Acorns: What Is It and How Does It Work?

Acorns is a micro-investing app designed to help individuals, especially beginners, start investing with minimal capital. Its core feature, Round-Ups, automatically rounds up your everyday purchases to the nearest dollar and invests the difference. Imagine buying a coffee for $2.50; Acorns would round that up to $3.00 and invest the extra $0.50 into a diversified portfolio.

Beyond Round-Ups, Acorns offers several other features:

Recurring Investments: Allows you to set up automatic daily, weekly, or monthly investments, regardless of your spending habits.
Found Money: Partners with various brands to offer cashback rewards that are invested directly into your Acorns account when you make purchases with them.
Retirement Accounts (Acorns Later): Provides access to tax-advantaged retirement accounts like Traditional IRAs, Roth IRAs, and SEP IRAs.
Checking Accounts (Acorns Checking): Offers a checking account with a debit card that facilitates Round-Ups and provides other banking features.
Acorns Earn: Rewards users with investment dollars when they shop at partner companies.
Acorns Early: A custodial investment account for children that allows you to start investing for their future.

The Costs: Decoding Acorns’ Fee Structure

The primary reason people question Acorns’ value is its fee structure. Acorns charges a flat monthly fee that varies depending on the subscription tier you choose. The tiered structure is as follows:

Acorns Personal ($3/month): Includes investing, retirement, and checking accounts, plus a debit card.
Acorns Family ($5/month): Includes all features of Acorns Personal, plus investment accounts for kids (Acorns Early).

While seemingly small, these monthly fees can significantly impact smaller accounts. Let’s illustrate with an example:

If you have a $100 balance in your Acorns Invest account and pay $3 per month, that equates to a 36% annual fee – astronomically high compared to traditional brokerages that often charge negligible or no fees for basic investing services.

However, as your account balance grows, the impact of the monthly fee decreases proportionally. For a $10,000 account balance, a $3 monthly fee translates to a 0.36% annual fee, which is more reasonable and competitive.

Weighing the Pros and Cons: Is It Worth It?

To determine if Acorns is a waste of money, let’s break down the advantages and disadvantages:

Pros:

Beginner-Friendly: Acorns simplifies investing, making it accessible to individuals who may be intimidated by traditional investment platforms.
Automatic Investing: The Round-Ups feature promotes consistent investing without requiring active decision-making.
Diversification: Acorns offers diversified ETF portfolios aligned with different risk tolerance levels, helping mitigate risk.
Educational Resources: Provides educational content and resources to help users learn about investing.
Multiple Account Types: Offers investment, retirement, checking, and custodial accounts, catering to various financial goals.

Cons:

Flat Monthly Fees: The fixed monthly fee structure can be expensive for smaller accounts, significantly impacting returns.
Limited Investment Options: Offers a limited selection of ETFs compared to larger brokerage firms.
No Individual Stock Trading: Does not allow users to trade individual stocks or more complex investment products.
Potential for Underperformance: While diversified, the performance of Acorns’ portfolios may not always match or exceed broader market benchmarks.
Fees Eat into Returns: For small balances the monthly fees can eat up the potential investment returns.

Who Should (and Shouldn’t) Use Acorns?

Acorns might be a good fit for you if:

You are a complete beginner with little to no investment experience.
You struggle to save and invest consistently.
You prefer a hands-off, automated approach to investing.
You have a relatively small amount to invest initially.
You value the convenience and simplicity of the app.

Acorns might NOT be a good fit for you if:

You have a larger investment portfolio and are comfortable managing your investments independently.
You want access to a wider range of investment options, including individual stocks, bonds, and mutual funds.
You are a day trader or actively manage your investments.
You want to minimize fees and optimize investment returns.
You already have an established investment strategy and platform.

Alternatives to Acorns: Exploring Your Options

If Acorns doesn’t seem like the right fit, consider these alternatives:

Betterment and Wealthfront: Robo-advisors that offer automated investment management with low fees and diverse portfolios.
M1 Finance: Combines robo-advising with the ability to customize your portfolio and invest in individual stocks and ETFs.
Robinhood: Offers commission-free trading of stocks, ETFs, and options, but lacks the automated features of Acorns.
Fidelity and Charles Schwab: Traditional brokerage firms that offer a wide range of investment products, research tools, and educational resources, often with no account minimums or maintenance fees.

The Verdict: Is Acorns a Waste of Money?

Ultimately, the decision of whether Acorns is a waste of money depends on your individual circumstances, financial goals, and investment experience. If you are a beginner looking for an easy and automated way to start investing, Acorns can be a valuable tool. However, be mindful of the fees, especially if you have a small account balance, and consider exploring alternative options as your investment knowledge and portfolio grow. Don’t let the ease of use fool you, do your research and check the rate of return against the fees.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Acorns

1. Is Acorns FDIC Insured?

The Acorns Checking account is FDIC-insured up to $250,000, just like any other bank account. However, the Acorns Invest and Acorns Later accounts are not FDIC-insured. They are subject to market risks, including the potential loss of principal.

2. How Does Acorns Make Money?

Acorns generates revenue primarily through monthly subscription fees. They may also receive revenue from Found Money partnerships and interest income on cash balances held in checking accounts.

3. Can I Withdraw My Money from Acorns at Any Time?

Yes, you can withdraw your money from Acorns at any time. However, keep in mind that selling investments may trigger capital gains taxes, depending on how long you’ve held the assets and the gains you’ve realized.

4. What are the Tax Implications of Investing with Acorns?

Investing with Acorns may have tax implications. You may be subject to capital gains taxes when you sell investments at a profit. Contributions to Traditional IRAs may be tax-deductible, while Roth IRA withdrawals in retirement are typically tax-free. Consult a tax professional for personalized advice.

5. What ETFs Does Acorns Invest In?

Acorns typically invests in a selection of low-cost exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that track various market indexes. These ETFs may include:

Large-cap stocks (e.g., S&P 500)
Small-cap stocks
International stocks
Real estate (REITs)
Corporate bonds
Government bonds

6. How Does Acorns Determine My Portfolio?

Acorns uses a risk assessment questionnaire to determine your risk tolerance and recommend a suitable portfolio. You can choose from several pre-built portfolios, ranging from conservative to aggressive.

7. Is Acorns Safe and Secure?

Acorns employs industry-standard security measures to protect your personal and financial information, including encryption, two-factor authentication, and fraud monitoring.

8. How Do I Cancel My Acorns Account?

You can cancel your Acorns account through the app or website. Be sure to liquidate your investments and transfer your funds to another account before canceling.

9. Can I Use Acorns for Day Trading?

No, Acorns is not suitable for day trading. It is designed for long-term investing and does not offer the tools or features necessary for active trading.

10. How Does Found Money Work?

Found Money is a cashback rewards program that partners with various brands. When you shop at participating retailers using a linked card, Acorns automatically invests a percentage of your purchase into your account.

11. Is Acorns Better Than a Savings Account?

For long-term financial goals, Acorns (investing) is generally better than a savings account because it offers the potential for higher returns. However, savings accounts are better for short-term goals and emergency funds due to their liquidity and safety.

12. Can I Link Multiple Bank Accounts to Acorns?

Yes, you can link multiple bank accounts to your Acorns account for Round-Ups and recurring investments. This allows you to diversify your funding sources and manage your finances more effectively.