Table of Contents

Is AT&T or Verizon Cheaper? A Deep Dive into Mobile Costs

The short answer: It’s complicated, but generally, AT&T tends to be slightly cheaper than Verizon for comparable unlimited plans, particularly when considering introductory offers and bundled deals. However, the best deal for you depends heavily on your individual data usage, the number of lines you need, and any potential discounts you qualify for, such as military, first responder, or student discounts. Don’t just look at the sticker price; carefully consider all fees, taxes, and potential overage charges.

Breaking Down the Cost: A Side-by-Side Comparison

Choosing a mobile carrier isn’t just about brand loyalty; it’s about getting the most value for your money. Both AT&T and Verizon are major players in the telecommunications industry, offering a range of plans and services. Let’s dissect the pricing structures and hidden costs to help you make an informed decision.

Unlimited Plans: The Head-to-Head Showdown

The bread and butter of modern mobile plans are unlimited data options. These plans often come with varying levels of premium data, hotspot allowances, and streaming perks. Here’s a general overview (prices may vary based on location and promotions):

AT&T: Typically offers multiple unlimited plans, ranging from basic unlimited with slower speeds to premium plans with more hotspot data and high-definition streaming. Their base unlimited plan often undercuts Verizon’s equivalent in price. Promotions and multi-line discounts can further sweeten the deal.
Verizon: Known for its robust network and premium service, Verizon’s unlimited plans often come with a higher price tag. While their network performance is consistently ranked high, that performance comes at a cost. They offer several unlimited tiers, typically differentiating them by the amount of premium data you get before potential throttling, hotspot data allowances, and included perks like Disney+ or Apple Music subscriptions.

Key Consideration: Pay close attention to data throttling and deprioritization. Both carriers may slow down your speeds if you exceed a certain data threshold during periods of network congestion, especially on their cheaper unlimited plans.

Limited Data Plans: A Dying Breed?

While unlimited plans are increasingly popular, limited data plans might still be a viable option for light users who primarily use Wi-Fi.

AT&T: AT&T has largely phased out limited data plans for individual use, focusing more on unlimited options.
Verizon: Verizon also leans heavily towards unlimited plans but may offer smaller data allowances.

Key Consideration: Overage charges can quickly add up with limited data plans. Carefully estimate your data usage to avoid unexpected bills.

Family Plans: Sharing is Caring (and Saving?)

Family plans are crucial for households looking to save money by pooling data and services.

AT&T: Generally offers attractive multi-line discounts on their unlimited plans, making them competitive for families. The more lines you add, the lower the per-line cost often becomes.
Verizon: Also offers family plan discounts, but the initial price point can be higher than AT&T. However, the added perks included in higher-tier Verizon plans may appeal to families, such as streaming subscriptions or international calling features.

Key Consideration: Calculate the total cost per line, including taxes and fees, to accurately compare family plan options.

Hidden Costs: The Devil is in the Details

Don’t be fooled by advertised prices alone. Hidden costs can significantly impact your overall bill.

Activation Fees: Both carriers typically charge an activation fee for new lines or devices.
Taxes and Fees: Federal, state, and local taxes, as well as regulatory recovery fees, can add a significant chunk to your monthly bill.
Equipment Costs: The cost of your smartphone, whether purchased outright or financed, needs to be factored into your overall expenses.
Insurance and Protection Plans: Device insurance plans can protect you against damage or loss, but they come at an additional monthly cost.

Key Consideration: Ask about all applicable fees and taxes upfront to get a clear picture of your total monthly cost.

Discounts and Promotions: Snagging a Sweet Deal

Both AT&T and Verizon frequently offer discounts and promotions to attract new customers and retain existing ones.

Military Discounts: Members of the military and veterans often qualify for significant discounts.
First Responder Discounts: First responders, such as police officers, firefighters, and EMTs, may also be eligible for discounts.
Student Discounts: Students can sometimes take advantage of special promotions or discounts.
Bundled Services: Bundling your mobile service with other services, like internet or TV, can lead to cost savings.
Trade-in Programs: Trading in your old device can net you significant credits towards a new phone.

Key Consideration: Carefully research all available discounts and promotions and ensure you meet the eligibility requirements.

Network Performance: Beyond the Price Tag

While price is important, network performance is arguably even more crucial. A cheaper plan is no bargain if you can’t make calls or access the internet reliably.

Verizon: Consistently ranked among the top carriers for network reliability and speed, particularly in rural areas.
AT&T: Offers strong network coverage, though it may not be quite as extensive as Verizon’s in some areas.

Key Consideration: Check coverage maps and read user reviews to assess network performance in your specific area.

Conclusion: Making the Right Choice

Ultimately, the “cheaper” option between AT&T and Verizon depends on your individual needs and circumstances. AT&T generally offers slightly lower prices, especially when factoring in discounts and promotions, but Verizon’s superior network performance might be worth the extra cost for some users. Carefully weigh your priorities, assess your data usage, and compare all available discounts to make an informed decision that fits your budget and connectivity needs.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What’s the cheapest unlimited plan on AT&T?

AT&T’s cheapest unlimited plan typically offers unlimited data but might have lower video streaming quality (standard definition) and less hotspot data. Check their website for the most up-to-date pricing and features.

2. What’s the cheapest unlimited plan on Verizon?

Verizon’s entry-level unlimited plan usually provides unlimited data, but it might have limitations on premium data (data that isn’t subject to throttling) and may exclude certain perks found in higher-tier plans.

3. Does AT&T or Verizon have better coverage in rural areas?

Generally, Verizon tends to have better coverage in rural areas compared to AT&T. However, coverage can vary significantly depending on the specific location. Consult coverage maps for both carriers to make an informed decision.

4. Do AT&T and Verizon offer family plan discounts?

Yes, both AT&T and Verizon offer discounts for multi-line accounts (family plans). The per-line cost typically decreases as you add more lines.

5. Are there any hidden fees with AT&T or Verizon?

Yes, be aware of potential activation fees, taxes, and regulatory recovery fees. Equipment costs (if you’re financing a phone) and insurance plans are also additional expenses.

6. What kind of discounts do AT&T and Verizon offer?

Both carriers offer discounts for military personnel, first responders, students, and sometimes bundled services (e.g., mobile and internet).

7. Do AT&T and Verizon throttle data speeds?

Yes, both carriers may throttle data speeds on their unlimited plans after you exceed a certain data threshold, especially during periods of network congestion. This is more likely to occur on their cheaper unlimited plans.

8. What is data deprioritization?

Data deprioritization means that your data speeds may be temporarily slowed down if you are in an area with heavy network traffic, even if you haven’t exceeded your data allowance. This is common on lower-tier unlimited plans.

9. Can I bring my own phone to AT&T or Verizon?

Yes, you can typically bring your own unlocked phone to both AT&T and Verizon. Make sure your phone is compatible with their network technology (CDMA for Verizon, GSM for AT&T).

10. What are the pros and cons of AT&T vs. Verizon?

AT&T Pros: Generally cheaper, competitive multi-line discounts, good network coverage.
AT&T Cons: Network coverage might not be as extensive as Verizon in all areas, customer service can be inconsistent.
Verizon Pros: Strong network reliability and speed, wide coverage area, premium services.
Verizon Cons: Generally more expensive, can have higher activation fees, throttling on lower-tier plans.

11. Which carrier has better customer service, AT&T or Verizon?

Customer service experiences can vary widely. Some users report positive experiences with AT&T, while others praise Verizon’s service. It often depends on the specific representative or agent you interact with.

12. Should I choose AT&T or Verizon based on 5G coverage?

Both AT&T and Verizon are actively deploying 5G networks. Verizon tends to emphasize their Ultra Wideband 5G, which offers the fastest speeds but limited availability. AT&T has a more widespread, but often slower, 5G network. Check coverage maps for both carriers to see 5G availability in your area.