Table of Contents

Is Receiving Stolen Property a Felony?

Yes, receiving stolen property can be a felony, but the answer isn’t always a straight “yes.” Whether it lands you with a felony charge depends heavily on the value of the stolen property and the specific laws of the state where the offense occurred. Think of it as a sliding scale: a stolen pen might get you a slap on the wrist (maybe), while a stolen car? That’s almost certainly felony territory.

Understanding the Crime of Receiving Stolen Property

Before we dive into the felony vs. misdemeanor distinction, let’s make sure we’re all on the same page about what constitutes “receiving stolen property.” At its core, the crime involves these key elements:

Receiving or Possessing: This means you either physically took control of the property or you knowingly had it in your possession or under your control.
Knowledge: This is crucial. You must have known, or had reasonable cause to believe, that the property was stolen. This is where intent comes into play. Simply stumbling upon a lost item isn’t enough; you need to suspect it’s stolen.
Intent to Deprive: You must have intended to keep the property from its rightful owner. This distinguishes receiving stolen property from, say, temporarily holding an item you suspect is stolen while trying to locate its owner.
The Property is Actually Stolen: This might seem obvious, but it’s a vital element. The property must, in fact, have been taken illegally.

Think of a situation where you buy a used laptop from a stranger in a parking lot for a ridiculously low price, with no paperwork. A reasonable person would probably suspect that laptop wasn’t obtained legally. That suspicion, combined with your purchase and keeping of the laptop, could form the basis of a receiving stolen property charge.

Felony vs. Misdemeanor: The Value Threshold

The magic number that often separates a misdemeanor from a felony is the value of the stolen property. Each state sets its own threshold. Below this threshold, you’re likely facing a misdemeanor. Above it, you’re potentially looking at felony charges.

Misdemeanor: These are generally considered less serious crimes, punishable by fines, community service, and potentially a short jail sentence (typically less than a year). The value threshold for a misdemeanor can vary widely, from a few hundred dollars to over a thousand in some states.
Felony: These are the big leagues, carrying much harsher penalties. A felony conviction can result in significant prison time (more than a year), substantial fines, and a permanent criminal record that can impact your ability to find employment, housing, and even exercise your right to vote.

Examples of State Thresholds: It’s important to research the laws specific to your state. A $500 threshold is one popular value. Keep in mind that the thresholds can change!

Factors Influencing the Charge

While the value of the stolen property is a significant factor, it’s not the only one. Other circumstances can influence whether you’re charged with a felony or a misdemeanor:

Prior Criminal Record: A history of similar offenses or other crimes can elevate a misdemeanor charge to a felony, especially if it involves repeat offenses.
Nature of the Stolen Property: Certain types of stolen property, such as firearms or vehicles, may automatically trigger felony charges regardless of their value.
Involvement in the Underlying Theft: If you were involved in the original theft of the property, even if you only received it afterwards, you may face more serious charges, including those related to the theft itself (burglary, larceny, etc.).

Potential Penalties for Receiving Stolen Property

The penalties for receiving stolen property can vary widely depending on the state, the value of the property, and the circumstances of the crime.

Misdemeanor Penalties: These typically include fines, community service, probation, and a short jail sentence (usually less than a year).
Felony Penalties: These can include lengthy prison sentences (ranging from one year to decades, depending on the severity of the crime), substantial fines, probation, and restitution to the victim (repaying them for their loss).

Beyond the immediate penalties, a conviction for receiving stolen property can have long-term consequences, affecting your ability to obtain employment, housing, and even travel.

Defenses Against a Receiving Stolen Property Charge

If you’ve been charged with receiving stolen property, it’s crucial to consult with a qualified criminal defense attorney. There are several potential defenses that can be raised, depending on the specific facts of your case. Some common defenses include:

Lack of Knowledge: Arguing that you didn’t know, and had no reasonable cause to believe, that the property was stolen.
Lack of Intent: Arguing that you didn’t intend to deprive the owner of the property. For example, you might have taken possession of the property with the intention of returning it to its rightful owner.
Illegal Search and Seizure: Arguing that the police obtained the stolen property through an illegal search or seizure, violating your Fourth Amendment rights.
Entrapment: Arguing that law enforcement induced you to receive the stolen property.
Mistake of Fact: Arguing that you honestly, but mistakenly, believed you were entitled to possess the property.

These defenses are complex and fact-specific. An attorney can evaluate the specifics of your situation and advise you on the best course of action.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

FAQ 1: What does “constructive possession” mean in the context of receiving stolen property?

Constructive possession means you have the power and intent to control the property, even if it’s not physically on your person. For example, if you hide stolen goods in a storage unit under your name, you have constructive possession of them.

FAQ 2: Can I be charged with receiving stolen property if I unknowingly bought it online?

Yes, you can, especially if the price was suspiciously low, or the seller’s information was vague or untraceable. The key is whether a reasonable person would have suspected the item was stolen based on the circumstances.

FAQ 3: What if I only borrowed the stolen property?

Even if you borrowed the property intending to return it, you could still face charges. The element of “intent to deprive” can still be present if you knowingly kept the property from the rightful owner, even temporarily. The length of time you held the property, and your reasons for doing so, would be critical.

FAQ 4: Is it a defense to say I didn’t know the exact person it was stolen from?

Generally, no. You don’t need to know who it was stolen from, only that it was stolen. The prosecution needs to prove you knew or had reason to know the property was taken illegally.

FAQ 5: What happens if the property is recovered before I’m charged?

The recovery of the property might influence the prosecutor’s decision on whether to press charges. However, the actus reus and mens rea (the act and intent) of the crime already occurred when you received the stolen property with the requisite knowledge and intent. The recovery is a mitigating factor, not a complete defense.

FAQ 6: Can I get a more lenient sentence if I cooperate with the police?

Yes. Cooperation with law enforcement can often lead to a reduced sentence. This might involve providing information about the original theft or identifying other individuals involved in the crime. This is considered a demonstration of remorse and a willingness to make amends.

FAQ 7: What’s the difference between receiving stolen property and theft?

Theft is the actual act of taking someone else’s property. Receiving stolen property is acquiring property that someone else has already stolen. You can’t be convicted of both for the same item. If you stole it, you’re guilty of theft, not receiving.

FAQ 8: How does “reasonable cause to believe” differ from “knowledge”?

“Knowledge” means you are aware the property is stolen. “Reasonable cause to believe” means the circumstances are such that a reasonable person would suspect the property is stolen, even if you didn’t have direct knowledge. The latter is a lower bar for the prosecution to clear.

FAQ 9: Can a business be charged with receiving stolen property?

Yes, a business can be charged if its employees or agents knowingly receive stolen property in the course of their employment. This is especially relevant in industries dealing with used goods or valuable materials.

FAQ 10: What is restitution in a receiving stolen property case?

Restitution is a court order requiring you to compensate the victim for their losses resulting from the crime. This can include the value of the stolen property, as well as any related expenses, such as repair costs or lost income.

FAQ 11: Does it matter if I paid for the stolen property?

Paying for the property doesn’t automatically make you innocent. The key is whether you knew, or had reason to believe, the property was stolen at the time you paid for it.

FAQ 12: If the person who stole the property isn’t caught, can I still be convicted of receiving stolen property?

Yes. Your guilt depends on your own actions and state of mind when you received the property, not on whether the original thief is apprehended.

Disclaimer: This information is for general guidance only and not a substitute for legal advice from a qualified attorney. Laws vary by state, and specific legal situations should be discussed with an experienced legal professional.