Table of Contents

Is SURS a Good Retirement Plan? A Deep Dive for Illinois Higher Education

Yes, SURS (State Universities Retirement System of Illinois) is generally considered a good retirement plan, especially for those who dedicate a significant portion of their career to Illinois public universities and community colleges. It offers a blend of defined benefit and defined contribution options, providing a foundation of retirement income supplemented by potential investment growth. However, like any retirement plan, its suitability depends heavily on individual circumstances, career trajectory, and financial goals. Let’s delve deeper.

Understanding the Landscape of SURS

SURS is a defined benefit plan at its core, meaning your retirement income is determined by a formula based on your years of service, salary, and a multiplier. This provides a predictable income stream, which is particularly valuable in retirement. However, SURS also offers a defined contribution component, giving members some control over their investments and potentially higher returns. The interplay between these elements is key to understanding the plan’s overall value.

Decoding the Components: Defined Benefit vs. Defined Contribution

The traditional defined benefit plan, referred to as the Traditional Benefit Package, provides a guaranteed monthly retirement income. The exact amount depends on factors we’ll discuss, but the principle is simple: you work, you contribute, and upon retirement, you receive a pre-determined pension payment. This predictability is a significant advantage, especially when compared to the uncertainties of solely relying on self-directed investments.

On the other hand, SURS offers two defined contribution plans: the Self-Managed Plan (SMP) and the Portable Benefit Package (PBP). In these plans, you, as a member, direct the investment of your retirement funds, choosing from a range of investment options. Your retirement income then depends on the performance of those investments. This offers greater control and potential for higher returns, but also carries more risk.

The Power of Longevity and Career Stability

SURS truly shines for individuals who spend a substantial part of their career within the Illinois public higher education system. The defined benefit component rewards longevity and career stability. The longer you work and the higher your final average salary, the larger your monthly pension check will be. For those who move in and out of the system frequently, or leave before vesting requirements are met (generally, five years of service credit), the benefits may be less substantial.

Navigating SURS: Pros and Cons

Like any retirement plan, SURS has its strengths and weaknesses.

Pros:

Defined Benefit Security: The Traditional Benefit Package provides a guaranteed income stream in retirement, reducing the risk of outliving your savings.
Employer Contributions: The State of Illinois contributes a significant portion of the funding, reducing the financial burden on individual members (although concerns about the state’s funding levels persist).
Disability and Survivor Benefits: SURS offers valuable protection in the event of disability or death, providing income for you or your beneficiaries.
Tax Advantages: Contributions are made on a pre-tax basis, reducing your current taxable income. Earnings grow tax-deferred until retirement.
Portability (with caveats): While not as portable as a 401(k), members who leave SURS before retirement can typically receive a refund of their contributions or roll over their accumulated benefits (depending on the plan and years of service).

Cons:

State Funding Concerns: The long-term financial health of SURS is tied to the State of Illinois, and concerns about underfunding have been a persistent issue.
Limited Investment Control (in Traditional Benefit Package): Members in the Traditional Benefit Package have no control over how their contributions are invested.
Complexity: Understanding the various plan options and their nuances can be challenging.
Pension Formula Limitations: The formula used to calculate benefits may not favor all individuals equally, particularly those with shorter tenures or lower salaries.
Potential for Benefit Adjustments: While unlikely, there is always a possibility that future legislation could alter the terms of the plan (although such changes typically only affect new members).

SURS FAQs: Your Burning Questions Answered

Here are some frequently asked questions to help you better understand SURS and its implications for your retirement planning:

FAQ 1: What are the eligibility requirements to participate in SURS?

Generally, anyone employed by a participating Illinois public university or community college in a position that requires at least half-time service is eligible to participate in SURS. However, certain categories of employment may be excluded, such as student workers or those covered by other retirement systems. Always confirm your eligibility with your employer’s human resources department or directly with SURS.

FAQ 2: How are SURS benefits calculated?

The calculation depends on the plan you are in. For the Traditional Benefit Package, the formula generally involves multiplying your final average salary (FAS), your years of service credit, and a benefit accrual rate. The accrual rate varies depending on your years of service, increasing as you stay longer within the SURS system. The Self-Managed Plan and the Portable Benefit Package benefits depend on your investment selections and returns.

FAQ 3: What is “final average salary” (FAS) in the context of SURS?

Final average salary is typically the average of your highest 48 consecutive months of earnings within the last ten years of your service. This is a critical factor in determining your pension benefit, so maximizing your earnings during those years can have a significant impact on your retirement income.

FAQ 4: Can I transfer my SURS benefits to another retirement plan if I leave my job?

Yes, under certain circumstances. If you leave your job before retirement and meet certain vesting requirements, you can typically receive a refund of your contributions or roll over your accumulated benefits to another qualified retirement plan, such as a 401(k) or IRA. However, the specific rules and options depend on the plan you are in and your years of service.

FAQ 5: What happens to my SURS benefits if I die before retirement?

SURS provides survivor benefits to your designated beneficiaries in the event of your death before retirement. The specific benefits depend on the plan you are in and your beneficiary’s relationship to you. Options may include a lump-sum payment, a monthly annuity, or a combination of both.

FAQ 6: How does Social Security interact with SURS?

Most SURS members also participate in Social Security. This means that you will contribute to and receive benefits from both systems. However, it’s important to understand how these benefits might interact and potentially offset each other, particularly concerning the Government Pension Offset (GPO) and Windfall Elimination Provision (WEP) rules.

FAQ 7: What are the Government Pension Offset (GPO) and Windfall Elimination Provision (WEP)?

The GPO can reduce or eliminate Social Security spousal or survivor benefits if you receive a pension based on work where you didn’t pay Social Security taxes (which is not applicable to SURS members because SURS members also pay Social Security taxes). The WEP can reduce your Social Security retirement benefits if you also receive a pension based on work where you didn’t pay Social Security taxes. Because SURS members also pay Social Security taxes, WEP does not usually apply to them. However, it is wise to consult with the Social Security Administration to verify your specific situation.

FAQ 8: How can I choose between the Traditional Benefit Package, Self-Managed Plan, and Portable Benefit Package?

The best choice depends on your risk tolerance, investment knowledge, and career goals. The Traditional Benefit Package offers security and predictability, while the Self-Managed Plan and Portable Benefit Package offer more control and potential for higher returns, but also greater risk. Consider consulting with a financial advisor to weigh the pros and cons of each option.

FAQ 9: Can I make voluntary contributions to SURS?

In most cases, no, you cannot make voluntary contributions to supplement your mandatory contributions to the Traditional Benefit Package. However, members in the Self-Managed Plan and Portable Benefit Package can often make additional contributions within certain limits.

FAQ 10: How is SURS funded, and what are the risks associated with underfunding?

SURS is funded through a combination of member contributions, employer contributions (primarily from the State of Illinois), and investment earnings. Persistent underfunding by the State of Illinois has been a major concern, potentially jeopardizing the long-term solvency of the system and raising questions about the security of future benefits. While legislative efforts have been made to address the funding gap, it remains an ongoing challenge.

FAQ 11: How can I stay informed about changes to SURS and my benefits?

It’s crucial to stay actively informed about any changes to SURS and how they might affect your retirement planning. Regularly check the SURS website (www.surs.org), attend informational seminars offered by SURS, and contact SURS directly with any questions you may have. You can also contact SURS at 800-275-7877.

FAQ 12: Should I consult with a financial advisor about my SURS benefits?

Yes, consulting with a qualified financial advisor can be extremely beneficial, especially when making decisions about which SURS plan to choose, how to allocate your investments (if applicable), and how to integrate your SURS benefits into your overall retirement plan. A financial advisor can provide personalized guidance based on your individual circumstances and goals.