Table of Contents

Where to Buy Dress Shirts, Reddit? A Style Savant’s Guide

So, you’ve ventured onto the digital plains of Reddit in search of the holy grail: the perfect dress shirt. Fear not, intrepid sartorial seeker! The answer, as always, is multifaceted and depends on your individual needs and preferences. But let’s cut through the noise and get straight to the prime contenders. For a solid starting point, consider these brands across different price points:

Budget-Friendly: Uniqlo, Amazon Essentials, Charles Tyrwhitt (during sales).
Mid-Range: Banana Republic, J.Crew, Nordstrom (house brands like Calibrate).
High-End: Brooks Brothers, Eton, Proper Cloth (for custom options).

However, the real secret lies in understanding why these brands are recommended, and how to navigate the overwhelming options available. This isn’t just about slapping a label on your chest; it’s about finding the shirts that fit you perfectly, reflect your personal style, and stand the test of time (and laundry cycles).

Finding Your Perfect Dress Shirt

The key to purchasing the right dress shirt lies in understanding fit, fabric, and function. Blindly following Reddit’s recommendations without considering these elements will leave you with a closet full of regrets.

Understanding Fit

Fit is paramount. A well-fitted shirt can elevate even the most basic ensemble, while a poorly fitted one can ruin an expensive suit. Consider these fits:

Slim Fit: Tapered through the waist and chest, ideal for athletic or slimmer builds. Be wary of tightness around the shoulders and chest, which restricts movement.
Modern Fit: A slightly relaxed version of slim fit, offering more room for comfort. A great option for most body types.
Classic Fit: The most generous fit, providing ample room in the chest, waist, and sleeves. Best suited for those who prefer a more relaxed silhouette or those who are larger in stature.
Custom/Tailored: The ultimate in fit. Provides a personalized fit that is tailored to your exact measurements. Brands like Proper Cloth and Indochino specialize in this.

Beyond the overall fit, pay attention to these specific areas:

Collar: Should fit snugly around your neck, allowing enough room for one finger between your neck and the collar when buttoned.
Shoulders: The shoulder seam should sit directly on top of your shoulder bone.
Sleeves: Sleeves should end where your thumb meets your wrist. When wearing a jacket, about half an inch of your cuff should be visible.
Body: The shirt should drape smoothly over your torso, without pulling or billowing.

Diving into Fabric

Fabric dictates comfort, durability, and overall appearance. The most common dress shirt fabrics are cotton, linen, and blends.

Cotton: The most popular choice, prized for its breathability, comfort, and versatility. Different types of cotton, such as Egyptian cotton, Pima cotton, and Sea Island cotton, offer varying levels of quality and softness.
Linen: Lightweight and breathable, perfect for warmer weather. However, linen wrinkles easily, so it’s best suited for more casual settings.
Blends: Cotton blends (e.g., cotton-polyester) offer enhanced wrinkle resistance and durability. While they may not be as breathable as pure cotton, they are often more affordable and easier to care for.
Oxford Cloth: Is a durable fabric that can be worn in either a casual or dressy style. Oxford cloth shirts are often paired with chinos or dress pants.
Poplin: Is a lightweight fabric that is smooth and wrinkle-resistant. Poplin shirts are a good choice for business or formal occasions.
Twill: Is a woven fabric that has a diagonal pattern. Twill shirts are often paired with jeans or dress pants.

Functionality is Key

Consider the intended use of your dress shirts. Are they for daily office wear, special occasions, or weekend outings?

For the Office: Opt for classic colors like white, blue, and gray in fabrics like cotton or cotton blends. Focus on wrinkle resistance and easy care.
For Special Occasions: Consider bolder colors, patterns, and luxurious fabrics like Egyptian cotton or linen.
For Casual Wear: Experiment with different textures, patterns, and collar styles. Oxford cloth and chambray are great choices for a more relaxed look.

Beyond the Brands: Hunting for Deals

Reddit often highlights excellent deals and sales. Keep an eye out for:

Seasonal Sales: Many retailers offer significant discounts during end-of-season sales (e.g., summer clearance, Black Friday).
Outlet Stores: Brands like Brooks Brothers and J.Crew have outlet stores where you can find discounted merchandise.
Online Marketplaces: Sites like eBay and Poshmark can be treasure troves for gently used or new-with-tags dress shirts.

Dress Shirt FAQs

1. What’s the best dress shirt color to start with?

White. A crisp white dress shirt is the cornerstone of any well-dressed man’s wardrobe. It’s versatile, timeless, and can be dressed up or down.

2. How do I measure my dress shirt size at home?

You’ll need a measuring tape. Measure your neck circumference, chest, waist, and sleeve length. Compare your measurements to the brand’s size chart (sizes vary).

3. What’s the difference between a spread collar and a point collar?

A spread collar has a wider distance between the collar points, making it suitable for wider ties and face shapes. A point collar has a narrower distance, making it a versatile choice for most occasions.

4. How should I care for my dress shirts to make them last?

Wash in cold water, avoid harsh detergents, and hang or lay flat to dry. Iron or steam as needed. Professional laundering is recommended for high-end shirts.

5. What does “non-iron” or “wrinkle-free” mean?

These shirts are treated with a chemical finish that resists wrinkles. While convenient, they may not be as breathable as untreated shirts.

6. What is a good fabric weight for a dress shirt?

A medium-weight fabric (around 3.5-4.5 oz) is a good starting point. Lighter weights are ideal for summer, while heavier weights offer more structure.

7. What’s the best way to shop for dress shirts online?

Read reviews, check the brand’s size chart carefully, and pay attention to the fabric composition. Look for retailers with easy return policies.

8. Are expensive dress shirts always better?

Not necessarily. While higher-priced shirts often feature superior fabrics and construction, you can find excellent quality at more affordable price points. It’s about finding the best value for your budget.

9. How many dress shirts should I own?

As a starting point, 5-7 shirts. This allows for enough variety and ensures you always have a clean shirt on hand.

10. What is the most versatile dress shirt cuff style?

The barrel cuff (button cuff) is the most versatile option. It can be worn in both casual and formal settings.

11. Should I always tuck in my dress shirt?

Generally, yes. Unless you’re wearing a very casual shirt (e.g., Oxford cloth with a relaxed fit) and the occasion is very informal, tucking in your dress shirt is the more polished look.

12. What brands offer custom dress shirts online?

Proper Cloth, Indochino, and Knot Standard are popular choices for custom dress shirts, offering a wide range of fabrics, fits, and customization options.

Ultimately, finding the perfect dress shirts is a journey of discovery. Experiment with different brands, fits, and fabrics to find what works best for you. Don’t be afraid to ask for help from salespeople or tailors, and always prioritize fit and comfort. Happy hunting, Redditors!