Hobby Lobby vs. Michaels: A Crafty Cost Comparison

The age-old question plaguing crafters everywhere: which is cheaper, Hobby Lobby or Michaels? The truth is, there’s no definitive, universal winner. It’s a nuanced battle decided by what you’re buying, when you’re buying it, and how strategically you wield those coupons! Let’s dive deep into the crafty trenches to dissect the pricing strategies, sales tactics, and overall value proposition of these two titans of the crafting world.

Breaking Down the Price Point Battlefield

While neither store consistently undercuts the other across the board, understanding their general approaches will equip you to make informed decisions.

Everyday Prices: A Close Call

At first glance, everyday prices are often strikingly similar between Hobby Lobby and Michaels. Basic supplies like paper, paints, and yarns tend to fall within the same ballpark. However, keep a keen eye on the details! Minor variations in size, quantity, or brand can swing the advantage one way or the other. Don’t assume parity – always compare apples to apples (or glitter to glitter, as it were).

The Coupon Conundrum: Game Changer!

This is where the playing field drastically shifts. Both retailers aggressively employ coupon strategies, but their methods differ significantly.

• Hobby Lobby’s 40% Off Coupon: This single coupon is legendary. It’s typically good for one regularly priced item and is nearly always available (excluding “sale” or “clearance” items). The sheer ubiquity of this 40% discount makes Hobby Lobby a strong contender for many purchases.
• Michaels’ Dynamic Discounts: Michaels offers a broader range of coupons, often percentage-based (20%, 30%, or even 50% off your entire purchase, sometimes with exclusions). They also feature category-specific coupons and targeted promotions for rewards members. This variety can be advantageous if you’re buying multiple items or something excluded from Hobby Lobby’s 40% off.

Essentially, Michaels requires more effort to find and leverage the best discounts, but the potential rewards can be substantial. Hobby Lobby provides a reliable, straightforward discount that’s easy to apply.

Sales Cycles and Clearance Shenanigans

Both stores run frequent sales across various departments. Here’s a general trend:

• Hobby Lobby: Tends to have more predictable, recurring sales. Look for weekly sales flyers detailing specific departments on discount. They also have an impressive clearance section with items deeply discounted, but selection can be hit-or-miss.
• Michaels: Sales are more event-driven, often tied to holidays or special occasions. Their clearance section is also worth exploring, and they occasionally offer steeper discounts on overstocked items.

The key here is to be patient and plan your purchases around these sales events. Sign up for email newsletters and download their apps to stay informed.

Private Label Power: Store Brands Matter

Both Hobby Lobby and Michaels boast their own lines of store-brand products, which often offer significant savings compared to name-brand alternatives.

• Hobby Lobby’s “Master’s Touch” (art supplies) and “I Love This Yarn!” are popular examples.
• Michaels’ “Artist’s Loft” (art supplies) and “Loops & Threads” (yarn) are their comparable offerings.

These private label brands can provide excellent quality at a fraction of the cost. Don’t dismiss them without a try – read reviews and experiment to see if they meet your needs.

Pro Tip: Price Matching and Beyond

Always be aware of price matching policies. Some stores will match competitors’ prices (including online retailers), potentially netting you even greater savings. Also, look for reward programs. Both retailers offer reward programs to get additional savings, or even cash-back incentives. Don’t forget to stack your discounts. For example, you could use a military discount on top of a coupon, or a rewards offer on top of a sale item.

Summary

Ultimately, the “cheaper” store depends on your specific shopping list. For single, regularly-priced items, Hobby Lobby’s 40% off coupon is hard to beat. However, for larger purchases, strategic coupon stacking and sales hunting at Michaels can yield greater overall savings. Diligent comparison shopping and a willingness to leverage every available discount are the keys to maximizing your crafting budget.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Does Hobby Lobby still offer the 40% off coupon?

Yes, Hobby Lobby typically offers a 40% off one regular-priced item coupon. However, this excludes sale items and clearance items, and there may be other specific exclusions listed on the coupon. Check their website or app for the most current details. The frequency of this coupon is nearly constant.

2. Can I use multiple coupons at Hobby Lobby?

Generally, no. Hobby Lobby’s primary 40% off coupon is limited to one per customer per day. However, they may occasionally offer other coupons or promotions that can be combined with existing sales.

3. Does Michaels offer a senior discount or a student discount?

Michaels does not have a standard senior or student discount. However, they frequently offer discounts to teachers, so check the current offers. It’s always worth asking customer service about any available promotions.

4. How do I find Michaels coupons?

Michaels coupons are readily available through their mobile app, email newsletters, and website. You can also find them in printed advertisements or through third-party coupon sites.

5. Are the quality of Hobby Lobby’s store-brand products any good?

Yes, many crafters find Hobby Lobby’s store brands, like Master’s Touch and I Love This Yarn!, to be of good quality for the price. It’s always a good idea to read online reviews and try out a small quantity before committing to a larger purchase.

6. Does Michaels price match?

Yes, Michaels does offer price matching. They will generally match the price of an identical item from select competitors (including online retailers). Be sure to check their official price matching policy for the most up-to-date details and restrictions.

7. What is the best day to shop at Hobby Lobby for sales?

Hobby Lobby’s sales cycle typically runs from Sunday to Saturday. New sales are usually revealed on Sunday. Check their website or app for current promotions.

8. What is the best day to shop at Michaels for sales?

Michaels sales are more event-driven, but they often release new promotions on Sundays. However, it’s best to check their website or app regularly for updated sales and coupon offers.

9. Do Hobby Lobby and Michaels offer online ordering?

Yes, both Hobby Lobby and Michaels have robust online ordering platforms. This allows you to shop from the comfort of your home and take advantage of online-exclusive deals.

10. Are there any specific items that are always cheaper at Hobby Lobby?

While not guaranteed, seasonal decor and home decor items often have very low prices at Hobby Lobby, especially with the 40% coupon.

11. Are there any specific items that are always cheaper at Michaels?

Specific brands and specialty items are likely to be cheaper at Michaels with the use of coupons. Sign up for rewards programs, and use them at the register and you may see a special percentage off coupon.

12. Which store has a better return policy?

Both Hobby Lobby and Michaels generally offer similar return policies. You can typically return items with a receipt within a specified timeframe (usually 60-90 days). Review their respective websites for detailed information and any restrictions.